The “Reasonable Man” and the Future of Non-racialism and Equality Before the Court
On 8 December 2018, Andile Mngxitama, the leader of Black First Land First (BLF), told supporters at a BLF rally in Tlokwe, Potchefstroom, that they should be “prepared to kill for our land, as much as we are prepared to die for our land. We mean it!”
Mngxitama also referred to remarks that Johann Rupert had made four days earlier in a Power FM interview, during which he responded to threats that had recently been made against him by the EFF. He jokingly said that he had longtime friends in the taxi industry, implying that they would come to his defence if he were attacked. Mngxitama responded to Rupert’s comments with the following peroration:
“Comrades I just want to make it very clear that Johann Rupert has declared war on us black people... Johann Rupert says he has control over the taxi industry bosses. We know what that means. Taxi industry bosses are people who are involved in killing other people. Johann Rupert says that if we touch him he is going to unleash on us the taxi industry people. Now here’s a message to Johann Rupert…
Pay the taxi industry bosses. It is okay. But here is the deal. For each one person that is killed by the taxi industry we will kill five white people. For every one black person we will kill five white people. You kill one of us, we will kill five of you! You kill one of us, we will kill five of you! Kill one of us, kill five of you! You kill one of us, we’ll kill five white people. We will kill the children! We will kill the women! We will kill anything that we find on our way!”
AfriForum laid a complaint against Mngxitama in the Johannesburg Magistrate's Court – sitting as an Equality Court – charging that his remarks constituted hate speech. On 2 May, Magistrate Nishani Beharie dismissed the complaint, finding that “viewed through the lens of the context within which the complaints were uttered”, she was satisfied that "the first and second respondents have rebutted any evidence of wrongdoing.” In effect, she accepted Mngxitama’s claim that the complaints against him were not to be taken literally but figuratively (despite the fact that he had clearly said that “we mean it!”).