Barack Obama epitomised the best of the tributes to Nelson Mandela on his 100th birthday. His message was full of wisdom and warmth; one feels sure that many South Africans, especially young people, were inspired by the American’s words, worthy of Madiba and his legacy to our country.
What a pity it is that others were not as successful – or as truthful – as President Obama. Our president, Cyril Ramaphosa, had the following to say: “Land expropriation without compensation is one of the key programmes that will take forward former president Nelson Mandela’s vision of a free South Africa.” Notably, President Ramaphosa was joined in this call by Jacob Zuma.
Most people know President Zuma and do not expect a great deal from him, but some must have been shocked at the unblushing misrepresentation of the Mandela position by President Ramaphosa. Those of us who sat in the Constitutional Assembly more than twenty years ago under the chairpersonship of Cyril Ramaphosa know that President Mandela believed no such thing. Nor did Mr Ramaphosa. He now says, “The process of expropriating land without compensation (EWC) would lead to enhancing the growth of South Africa and increase agricultural production and food security.”
The Constitution provides in Clause 25 for land redistribution (certainly that had the support of all of us, including President Mandela and Mr Ramaphosa). It also provided for expropriation for public purposes against payment of “fair and equitable” compensation. Implicit in that is the idea that if it was fair and equitable, then EWC would be within the terms of the Constitution. Mr Ramaphosa has yet to explain at what point expropriation without compensation becomes fair and equitable and ceases to be theft.
If this is what President Mandela wanted and stood for, why was this position not at least put to us as the position of the ANC? Why did Chairman Ramaphosa not insist on this when he was the master of the process, with some negotiators eating out of his hand?
The president must explain which land will be targeted for EWC. Only land that was stolen by White people from Black people? Land that was stolen from Black people by other Black people?