The B-BBEE Amendment Bill --- would Biko have approved?
Even though it is 20 years since South Africa achieved it's freedom, it is incontrovertible that there needs to be a programme of "corrective action" (regstellende aksie) or "recoupment" for those previously disadvantaged under apartheid. The dilemma is how to achieve that legitimate goal without perpetuating a Verwoerdian race obsession, that horribly clashes with the cherished dream of a prosperous South African rainbow nation. I made a proposal in the Working group on the B-BBEE that will go a long way to solving that dilemma. It requires the insertion of only one preposition and one date.
The Bill does fundamentally three things. It entrenches race into South African law and does so 20 years after 1994, by advantaging previously disadvantaged individuals (PDI) in terms of procurement by the State and state organs; it creates a BBBEE Commissioner, with powers not dissimilar to the Spanish Inquisition, within the Department; it gives the Minister unprecedented power to amend codes and interfere through his employee, the Commissioner. The Bill also rightly addresses "fronting", which is, in any case, the common law crime of fraud.
This Bill will re-racialise South Africa. It is about the Manyi ideology, not the Mandela vision. It will hold back our infrastructure development, government's service delivery and industrialisation programme because it seeks a future that marginalises one section of our population and one with huge skills, energy and experience. It is a bit like refusing to use one of one's really good bulls to help cover your herd of cows. The Bill represents the spirit of whining and whinging from a position of victimhood, exactly as the government has whined when the British Government paid South Africa a genuine compliment by announcing that it was terminating most of it's aid to us.
In my view Steve Biko would have opposed a Bill like this, because the subliminal message is that blacks are inherently less competent than other races. There is no provision for a "sunset clause" and its absence re-inforces the iniquitous stigma and lie, that blacks cannot compete in the open market of the new South Africa even after 20 years of freedom.
Nothing holds back an entrepreneur, whether in business or sport, if there is the freedom to get ahead. Without in any way being flippant, blacks, as growers, distributors, transporters, retailers monopolise the huge dagga trade. Only seriously good entrepreneurs and risk managers could do that. They also dominate the multi-billion rand combi taxi industry as well as the world of stokvels and, indeed, the thousands of entrepreneurial independent churches. Are there fiercer defenders of property rights or guys with bigger b***s, than these serious risk takers?