This is a response to John Kane-Berman’s article of 03 June (see here) titled “Gaza: Hamas’ horrific game”.
First, let us note that Gordin is acquainted with John Kane-Berman (JKB) and admires much of his work, especially the two books, Soweto: Black Revolt White Reaction (1979) and Between Two Fires: Holding the Liberal Centre in South African Politics (2017).
Second, it’s clear from JKB’s piece that he doesn’t know very much about Israel/Palestine, the situation in general and its history. But this doesn’t matter much because the main aim of his article is to construct some sort of simulacrum of what Hamas supposedly “engineered” on the Israeli /Gaza border and the strategy of “the African National Congress and its allies in the South African Communist Party and Umkhonto we Sizwe, [who] knew that they had no chance of overcoming the National Party government’s security forces. But [who knew nevertheless] they could provoke violence in the expectation that it would provoke excessive counter violence, which would then be portrayed in the media as the slaughter of innocent protesters.”
What JKB seems to be suggesting is that it was “standard” (ANC/SACP) “revolutionary strategy” to incite youth to attack police with, say, petrol bombs. If they succeeded in intimidating or killing the police then that was a win. If the police shot and killed them in response, then that was a win as well – because it served to increase popular hatred of the “Boer enemy,” allowing for the mobilization of the masses at funerals and bringing down yet further opprobrium on the regime, etc.
JKB’s argument seems then to be that Hamas was doing something similar, though perhaps not identical: sending its operatives to breach the fence (unarmed) and thereby putting Israel in a situation where it would either lose control of the border and allow thousands of Gazans into Israel or kill “unarmed protestors”. If the former, well then great; if the latter, then that creates new martyrs for the cause, damages Israel’s reputation internationally and highlights the murderous oppression of Gaza, etc.
Okay, let’s accept for the sake of the discussion that what is sketched above was indeed ANC/SACP “revolutionary strategy”. But there is nonetheless a problem. Can JKB name one incident in SA from the late-1970s and 1980s (the period to which he’s clearly referring) that fits the bill – a large group of people “sent in” to attack the police, whose deaths were then used to stoke anti-government opprobrium? Maybe he can; but we can’t. It’s a significant issue; and we’ll get back to it in a moment.