Judge Mogoeng in good company for expressing political opinions
11 March 2021
High Court Judge Siraj Desai, has an illustrious record of political involvement and activism on behalf of the Palestinian cause, and yet attracted no censure, either while in office or afterwards. In 2009 the Judge went on lead a group of 15 South African activists who flew to Egypt to join a planned Freedom march on the Gaza strip in support of the Palestinians, but were stopped by Egyptian troops. This event was organized by the Palestine Solidarity Alliance (PSA).
Judge Desai again entered the polical arena in 2011 with his own opinions when he promoted boycotts and sanctions against Israel and went on to say that the Israeli occupation of Palestine was “one of the longest continuing breaches of human rights in the world.” He was involved with the screening of an anti-Israel film at the District Six Museum and Presided over the South African support committee of the notorious and one sided third Russell Tribunal in 2013.
As late as 2020 Judge Desai as a guest of the Muslim Judicial Council engaged publicly with the Palestinian Ambassador Hanan Jarrar, calling for solidarity with the Palestinian people and criticizing the “Deal of the Century” accords in the Middle East.
So, it appears to be fine for a sitting judge to express his political opinions as long as they are targeted at condemning Israel!