On Saturday at a “homecoming rally” in his home town of Tlokwe in the North West the Black First Land First leader, Andile Mngxitama, issued a barely veiled call for the killing of South Africa’s white minority. He stated that “We mean it when we say, ‘Land or death!’ We are prepared to kill for our land, as much as we are prepared to die for our land.”
Last week in his PowerFM interview the businessman Johann Rupert had joked that a friend of his, Jabu Mabuza, was chairman of the taxi association, which was also one of the early tenants of Business Partners. “So I also have my own army when those red guys come.” Riffing of this in his address Mngxitama claimed that Rupert had “declared war on us black people.” He stated that “For each one person that is killed by the taxi industry we will kill five white people. For every one black person we will kill five white people.” Working himself and the crowd (such as it was) into a frenzy he declared: “We kill their children, we kill their women, we kill their dogs, we kill their cats, we kill anything that comes before us!”
Despite being widely reported on in the South African media these statements have received, as of the time of writing, zero coverage in Western publications such as the BBC or Guardian. The same happened with Malema’s recent attack on Pravin Gordhan as “a dog of White monopoly Capital”. “We must hit the dog until the owner comes out”, the EFF leader told a crowd outside the Zondo commission hearings, “And once the owner comes out we must deal decisively with the owner.” Again, no coverage evident on the BBC or Guardian websites.
Then there was the far more minor controversy last month over UCT student Masixole Mlandu’s use of the slogan, “ONE SETTLER, ONE BULLET!!” in the acknowledgment section of his honours dissertation, and then in a Tweet the following day. “One settler, One bullet. Each bullet will take us closer to freedom,” he wrote there. Again, despite being covered in the SA media, no coverage followed on the Guardian or BBC websites or anywhere else.
By contrast, such publications have in the past been quick to report on examples of crass racial comments and slurs by white (and Indian) South Africans, let alone acts of violence such as in the “coffin case”. The BBC website, for instance, has a number of reports on the cases of inter alia Penny Sparrow, Kessie Nair, Mabel Jansen, Vicki Momberg and Adam Catzavelos. With the exception of Jansen these individuals were intellectually limited or mentally disturbed and of no public standing. Apart from Nair’s these comments were made in private or semi-private settings, and were not intended for public consumption. All suffered severe repercussions as a result of images or videos of their grossly offensive and inflammatory comments being leaked into the public domain and then going “viral”.
By any objective journalistic measure the extreme racial rhetoric emanating from volksverhetzers like Malema, Mngxitama, and Mlandu should be regarded as equally newsworthy.