In the preface to his wonderful book of essays, Reappraisals: Reflections on the Forgotten Twentieth Century, the late Tony Judt wrote of the "perverse contemporary insistence on not understanding the context of our present dilemmas ... on seeking actively to forget rather than to remember, to deny continuity and proclaim novelty on every possible occasion."
I was reminded of these words while watching the interminable Israeli self-justifications on TV during the recent bombing of Gaza. Neither the missile-weary residents of southern Israel nor the representatives of the army and government were able to frame the conflict in any but the most context-less, self-serving and solipsistic of terms. The Palestinians of Gaza were launching attacks on Israel without provocation and Israel was well within its rights to respond as massively as it did. Period.
Is that really all there is to it? Is that the full and only truth? Is there no history to what is going on here - no context?
Judt, of course, was not referring specifically to Israel (though he was the author of a number of penetrating essays on the conflict here), but to the West as a whole, particularly the post-communist arrogance that lead directly to follies such as Fukuyama's The End of History and Bush's blind march into Iraq. But Israel, as it happens, is the archetype of the forgetfulness of which Judt wrote; the mother lode of national obliviousness.
Israelis have, by and large, swept the past 45 years under the carpet - at least the parts that have to do with the Palestinians. Every act of resistance comes out of nowhere; every rocket from Gaza is unprovoked. There was no ethnic cleansing in 1948, no occupation in 1967 and no invasion of Lebanon in 1982. There are no roadblocks in the West Bank, no Israeli buffer zones on what used to be Palestinian farming land in Gaza, no gunboats preventing Gaza fisherman from fishing in international waters, no nighttime raids on Palestinian homes. Nothing. Tabula rasa.
Israelis are able to demonstrate against the cost of living without making any logical connection between the economy and the crippling expense of the occupation and the enormous army that maintains it. Party leaders run on election planks in which the occupation barely features. Politicians threaten to cancel agreements that they themselves made redundant years ago. Military spokesmen speak of Hamas provocations without mentioning the Israeli actions that precede virtually every round of firing.