Liberals must move on, the United Democratic Front is long dead
Loosely defined liberals opposed apartheid in favour of an anti-nationalist inclusive framework based on rights and freedoms for all. There are some myths about liberals in general and South African liberals in particular that continue to persist, the most prevalent being that all liberals are of the Democratic Alliance's historical tradition or that all liberals are white. So often do people speak of 'white liberalism' that it has become a collocation.
The reality couldn't be further from the truth. There are, in fact, liberals (of all races and outside the DA) who not only feel contempt towards the DA but exist in a state of paralysis over the moral demise of the African National Congress (ANC). The existential crisis stems from the fact that it can no longer be said with confidence that the ANC is the people’s party; governing with concern for the poor and constitutional freedoms. Today they criticise the ANC from the sidelines, but seem unable to lend their critique the weight of credibility by shifting allegiance.
Sentiment is not the exclusive folly of the poor and uneducated as is often intimated. Indeed it’s a fair wager that sentiment is more easily held by those who can afford it, those for whom nostalgia is more precious than service delivery. There is nothing ignoble about loyalty, but rather it be to values. The trouble is that while good men with good intentions sit about wringing their hands, immersed in immobilising nostalgia and self-reflection, mercenary opportunists are ransacking the country throughout all levels of government virtually unabated, with ever increasing vigour and steadfastness of purpose. The more explicit examples of the looting being Jacob Zuma's palatial home at tax payers' expense and Hlaudi Motsoeneng's management of the SABC as his own personal fiefdom.
There still remains a hurdle, in Gauteng and other parts of the country, of imagining a democratic government that does not come from the tradition of the UDF and ANC. The geopolitics of liberalism in South Africa, are a separate but interesting conversation. It would be irresponsible to deal in absolute generalisations, but as centres of power in South Africa there is a palpable ideological schism between the Western Cape school of liberalism and the Gauteng school. A schism that is emblematic of the divide that separates the liberals of the Democratic Alliance (DA) of today with the liberals associated with the United Democratic Front (UDF) of old.
It is not that the beliefs differ fundamentally in the main but their approach to the liberation movement does. As the winds of change blew across South Africa and even as the liberation movement won, the Democratic Party (DP), subsequently the DA, stood obstinately head to wind, not shifting gear from its position as vanguard of liberalism to ally of the populists. This belligerence did not sit well with many including those who admired the liberal tradition associated with the Progressive Party (progs). Why could it not reach some partnership with the ANC as suggested by the likes of Allister Sparks in 1990? This recalcitrance has earned the die-hards labels such as ‘stuck-in-the-mud’ liberals or more harshly the ‘Taliban of liberalism’, both terms used by Max du Preez.