WE were just wondering, here at the Mahogany Ridge, about Home Affairs Minister Malusi Gigaba’s bonzo porkie that some 30 000 children were being trafficked in or through South Africa each year.
It was once said there were three types of falsehood: lies, damned lies and statistics. That suggestion, popularised by Mark Twain, may have held a certain currency back in the late 19th century, but it seems hopelessly antiquated and inadequate these days; the ranks of dishonesty have in recent times swollen to include the official version, market research and shareholder interests, to name a few.
And now we have cabinet ministers’ replies to questions in parliament. For it was a query from the Democratic Alliance’s Haniff Hoosen about child trafficking – the alleged basis for the disastrous new visa regulations – that resulted in what many have generously described as a wee exaggeration from Gigaba.
According to Hoosen, only 23 cases of child trafficking have been uncovered in the past three years. Gigaba, he said, was grossly distorting the figure “to save his own skin” and legitimise the draconian visa regulations that are killing the country’s tourism industry.
For the record, Gigaba has denied he made up the figure but did suggest, though, that others may have done so on his behalf. On average, he explained, home affairs officials visited three shelters a quarter and by interviewing “designated social workers” were able to ascertain why and how such victims entered the country.
From this, it’s unclear exactly how the officials then arrived at the figure of 30 000 cases from just a monthly chat with persons who admittedly do, as a matter of course, talk up problems. For all we know, a pocket calculator may been involved and some fiddling with string. But the main thing is that Gigaba is sticking to his guns. Even if they’re aimed at his feet. He can be rather pigheaded in that way.