I was reading James Myburgh’s interesting piece on transformation supposedly killing South Africa, and found myself reflecting on how far we really are from our nation building objectives as a people, because I realised that the opinion being expressed by James in this piece actually represents the views of many South Africans who feel excluded from this South Africa that we are currently building, hence arguments about whether white South Africans should stay or go currently enjoy much traction amongst the various sections of our society, as outlined by a couple of articles written within this forum over the past couple of weeks or so.
To hammer this point home further, a mate of mine from my varsity days who is a highly intelligent chap, a qualified professional with experience at a senior level within multinational corporations and who has also lived abroad and hence has had much exposure (he’s not parochial) had this to say on social media in a post over the past week, “the Mandela project didn’t work. It was superficial and did not address the hard truths. Stay or go, it really doesn’t matter unless we deal with the underlying issues. The first thing being structural race-based inequality.”
Different groupings within the very same society showing diverse perspectives on a topical issue, nothing new there, apart from the fact that the issue that these views are being expressed about will determine whether South Africa becomes or does not become what former President Thabo Mbeki spoke about in a Nelson Mandela memorial lecture at Wits in 2006, “the great masses of our country every day pray that the new South Africa that is being born will be a good, a moral, a humane and a caring South Africa, which, as it matures, will progressively guarantee the happiness of all its citizens.” Idealistic stuff right, but are we anywhere near achieving such high existential ideals as a people, and if not why?
Well, to quote former President Mbeki again, in his 1978 speech, The Historical Injustice, “All societies therefore necessarily bear the imprint, the birth-marks of their own past. Whether to a greater or lesser extent must depend on a whole concatenation of factors, both internal and external to each particular society.”
We must start off by acknowledging the fact that not too long ago, those who held political and economic power considered it appropriate (despite the convenient denialism of many in the current epoch) to instil policies that ensured the marginalisation and subjugation of the black African majority.
This is the history which we come from and that we are trying to break out of, but we will never do so until we acknowledge that this history has a direct bearing on where we find ourselves today and the fact that we have an economy, which is still to a large extent characterised by mostly white males being at the top of the food chain (despite persistent cries of white victimhood in this regard, this remains an empirical fact) and the black, African masses being at the very bottom and still largely excluded from the mainstream.