The article “SAJBD calls for reinstatement of Dr Bridget Farham as editor of SAMJ” by Wendy Kahn refers. The article is written by somebody who is completely unaware of the situation. Kahn has portrayed numerous false claims, and it is imperative that an objective and factual view be put forward, coming from the person who the initial editorial in question was directed to and impacted the most. That would be me. I therefore found it prudent to set the record straight, as the picture painted of that of an editor “ousted” on unfair grounds and having her “freedom of speech” imposed upon is wholly inaccurate.
I am a frequent commentator on the conflict in Gaza and was approached by a colleague to write an editorial for the SAMJ on the current situation. The focus would be, as have all my writings in the past, on the systematic weaponisation of health by Israel in Gaza- the way healthcare facilities and healthcare workers have been deliberately and inhumanely targeted and killed.
This isn’t a novel concept, and the sheer scale of health care destruction in Gaza has attracted the outcry of doctors around the world. Reports have been published in reputable journals, including The Lancet and British Medical Journal. In his editorial published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA), Dr Matthew Wynia from the Centre for Bioethics and Humanities at the University of Colorado made three unimpeachable points:
– First, health professionals should condemn dehumanisation and acts of genocide.
– Second, health professionals should vigorously oppose both antisemitism and anti-Muslim hatred.
– Third, health professionals have special responsibilities to speak out against certain war crimes.