The last weeks have seen our biggest Sunday newspaper devote many pages to the bitter dispute between the friends and enemies of Israel and this was followed by an attack by BDS (Boycott, Disinvestment and Sanctions – an ultra-anti-Israeli group) on Jewish candidates for membership of the Constitutional Court.
We all know the moves in this game – bitter attacks on Israel as an allegedly apartheid and racist state, an equally frantic defence of Israel by its supporters and, quite often, an attempt to smear anyone Jewish as an implicit Zionist.
BDS is a nasty organisation, quite rightly banned in many countries for its effectively anti-semitic propaganda. But why does South Africa feature these regular Punch and Judy shows over Israel/Palestine? Why the fascination with this old quarrel?
Under the Mbeki presidency huge amounts of cabinet time were devoted to intensive discussion of this issue with the apparent objective of a South African intervention to “solve” this problem. This was always ludicrous: the ANC was so publicly committed to the Palestinian side that there was never the slightest chance that Israel would view South Africa as having impartial standing. And Israel, in any case, has long ceased to want or need any kind of third-party adjudication.
The answer would seem to lie in a nostalgia for the glory days of the struggle. With South Africa liberated, ANC eyes fastened on Israel as another Western imposition in the Third World and the idea was that the anti-apartheid crusade could be re-started in order to “liberate” (i.e. destroy) Israel. BDS has simply built on this idea, trying to re-focus all the old anti-apartheid tactics against Israel.
There is not the slightest chance that this will succeed. No country of any economic significance operates boycotts, sanctions or disinvestment against Israel. Unlike the South African case there is no Third World or Communist bloc trying to isolate it. Russia and China are both happy to have a full range of economic relations with Israel. BDS often stoops to petty campaigns with an anti-Semitic flavour because its stated objectives are quite beyond its reach.