Parliament invites economic and political damage with EWC vote – IRR
The decision by a majority in South Africa’s Parliament to adopt a report recommending that the Bill of Rights be amended to facilitate Expropriation without Compensation (EWC) is yet another self-imposed hindrance to the prosperity that the country so desperately seeks.
The IRR has consistently warned that the entire policy thrust of EWC is inimical to investment and to economic growth – as we have heard from business people, both from South Africa and abroad. It starkly contradicts the government’s own nominal recognition of the importance of policy certainty. It will do nothing other than undermine South Africa’s economic prospects.
All South Africans can expect to pay a price for this as investors hold off on sinking their money into the country, with opportunity costs measured above all in jobs and wealth forfeited.
In addition, EWC offers nothing to address the failings of land reform, since these failings have never been shown to be linked to compensatory requirements. As a land reform measure, EWC will be more of a distraction from addressing the real problems than a part of any solution to them.
Beyond the economic damage, this measure has implications for the country’s constitutional order.