JSC should be strengthened to better defend rule of law
29 November 2022
Freedem Under Law (FUL) today released a new report, titled A Review of the Activities of the South African Judicial Service Commission 2009 to 2022, which reviews the performance of the Judicial Service Commission for the period.
Over the last 12 years, the JSC has attracted much attention and criticism regarding its conduct vis-à-vis both its appointment and its disciplinary obligations. FUL has closely monitored the JSC and has on many occasions reacted to lapses on the part of the JSC and its commissioners, and to ineptitude in the performance of its constitutional mandate. FUL has been, and continues to be, involved in litigation against the JSC, particularly in respect of its failures to execute its disciplinary function.
The report highlights key deficiencies in the composition and operation of the JSC and makes remedial recommendations and proposals to address both the structural problems inherent in the JSC, as well as the challenges in its current processes.
For years now the JSC has been prone to political interference in respect of appointments of judges and the report argues that the JSC should be reconstituted to include more senior judges and fewer party-political appointees.