SAJBD welcomes Mcebo Dlamini apology for antisemitic comments

14 December 2020

Today, the former Wits SRC President Mcebo Dlamini and the SA Jewish Board of Deputies (SAJBD) engaged in mediation facilitated by the SA Human Rights Commission (SAHRC).  The mediation took place at the Johannesburg Holocaust and Genocide Centre (JHGC).  This was in response to comments made by Dlamini in 2015, in which he showed admiration for Adolf Hitler and delved into stereotypical antisemitic tropes about Jews.  The SAJBD lodged a formal complaint against him at the SAHRC at the time.

Following the meeting, SAJBD Vice President Zev Krengel said that Dlamini’s apology was truly remorseful.  “The sincerity with which he acknowledged the hurt that he caused our community was palpable.” In Krengel’s words, “this understanding prompted him to make an unequivocal apology.  His recognition that the statements were antisemitic, hurtful and offensive, together with his genuine apology, enables us to heal from the hurt he caused.  It is important for us as a community, and as South Africans, to identify when genuine remorse is expressed.  It is equally important for us to accept a sincere apology of this nature as it enables us to move forward.”

Following today’s reconciliation Dlamini apologised for his comments (attached) and attended a facilitated educational engagement the permanent exhibition at the JHGC.

Professor Karen Milner, Chairperson of the SAJBD Gauteng Council, noted, “We try wherever possible to take a restorative approach to justice.  Such an approach follows a process by which the offender acknowledges what he or she has done wrong, and expresses genuine remorse and regret.  Dlamini has met these criteria, and is a successful example of what is possible with this approach.”

LETTER OF APOLOGY TO THE JEWISH COMMUNITY AND ALL THOSE AFFECTED

In 2015 I uttered statements about Jews and Israelis that were not only provocative but also extremely offensive. It is only in retrospect that I began to appreciate how much my statements were both ill-advised and to a certain extent dangerous because they ignored the kind of trauma that they caused. As someone who is interested in politics and how they can be used to advance a better world for all I should have known better. But consciousness is not something that you miraculously arrive at but you journey. My journey has made me appreciate that I was wrong and there is no possible excuse for what I said and there can be no way to reverse how it affected others. What I can do though is to supplement my apology with actions as testimony that I am truly remorseful.

I am committed to engage literature that will assist me in learning about the history of Jewish and Israeli people to understand deeply why my sentiments were offensive. Once I have this in-depth knowledge I commit to teaching others about the knowledge that I acquired. But beyond this I take serious interest in the history of all oppressed people in the world so that I do not repeat the same mistake. Once I have enough resources I want to travel to Israeli so that I understand their culture, tradition, belonging and how their present is shaped by their past. This I think will also help me in my growth as someone who is interested in politics of the world. I also want to have a guided tour at the JHGC followed by a facilitated engagement with one of the facilitators at the JHGC. I understand these acts alone might not be enough and I am therefore open to any other recommendation that might assist me in demonstrating my penance.

My act is not mitigated by the fact that I was in a leadership position when I said these statement. I had influence on a number of people whom were possibly convinced by what I had said. I highly regret using the platform that I had at the time in such a harmful way, the way I acted was undoubtedly an abuse of power. I have throughout the years met with various people both inside and outside the Jewish community who have helped understand how serious my transgression was. I have also been made aware that my statements were anti-sematic, which is a form of racism. As someone who grew up in South Africa and was/still is affected by the vestiges of apartheid I should have been more sensitive to that.

In conclusion I want to add that I have grown as, matured and have a better understanding. It is because of this that, in good faith, I hope that my apology with be accepted as sincere and honest. This apology is well thought out and is a result of extensive consultation. I have thought very deeply about the kind of leader I want to be and it is definitely not a leader that spreads hate and rejoices at the misfortunes of others.

Mcebo Dlamini

ENDS

Issued by Charisse Zeifert, Head: Communications, SAJBD, 14 December 2020