To read the statement of the DA Federal Executive about their investigation into the management of Cape Town under Patricia De Lille is a deeply disturbing experience. Poor leadership, degeneration of trust, misdirecting Council officials, failure to allow officials to do their jobs, interfering with project plans, gross misconduct, gross dereliction of duty, lying to Council over a lengthy period of time both about the loss of revenue from the Transport and Urban Development Authority and about the upgrades in her own home, mismanagement of the water crisis, responsibility for the city having its audit status down-graded - the list goes on and on.
The ANC has opportunistically withdrawn its motion of no confidence (even though it had cited many of the items above) and may now swing round to support De Lille but previous reports that as many as 59 DA councillors might support De Lille will now presumably be shelved. Given that the party's FedEx itself has mandated a no confidence vote it is hard to see how any DA councillors can defy that instruction without risking their own seats.
The DA has moved very slowly to deal with De Lille because it fears a repetition of the difficulties it encountered when it attempted to dismiss Peter Marais as Mayor in 2001. However, even if one assumes that it now smoothly removes De Lille, many questions remain.
Let us assume, for the sake of argument, that the DA charges are correct. And let us go back to 2003 when De Lille formed the Independent Democrats as a result of floor-crossing. In the 2004 legislative elections the ID garnered 1.7% of the vote (269,765 votes), though it was clearly a regional party with most of its support in the Western and Northern Cape. In the 2006 local elections it sustained its vote, this time taking 2.0% on a lower turnout.
This meant that in Cape Town the ID was an obvious component of the coalition that Helen Zille was then putting forward in order to become the city's first DA Mayor. To the astonishment of her own party members De Lille decided, however, to side with the ANC against the DA. This led to growing trouble within the ID, culminating in a disastrous by-election result when its voters showed overwhelmingly that they were hostile to De Lille's alliance with the ANC. Only then did De Lille accept her voters' verdict. These ructions did not help the ID and in the 2009 legislative elections the ID total fell to a mere 0.92% (162,915 votes) and it became clear that De Lille's boomlet was over.
Hence De Lille's decision to merge the ID into the DA in August 2010 - although De Lille retained membership of the ID until 2014 when, at long last, the ID was dissolved. Then in March 2011 De Lille was elected Mayor with the support of the DA leadership, thus displacing Dan Plato who had served quite blamelessly in succession to Helen Zille. After five years the DA again nominated De Lille as their mayoral candidate in the 2016 municipal elections. This was widely understood to be part of a package deal agreed with De Lille in return for the effective takeover of the ID by the DA.