29 April 2016
All of us who left the ANC with a heavy heart after Polokwane knew that Zuma was going to bring the presidency into serious dispute. As soon as he took office, he acted decisively to destroy the Scorpions and to corrupt the criminal justice system. He gave scant regard to his oath of office.
Mpshe did the same. Today’s decision, read by Judge Aubrey Ledwaba, laid bare the undermining of our Constitution by Mokotedi Mpshe who, like Zuma, broke his oath office too. Instead of acting without fear or favour, he acted secretly, improperly and irrationally. He provided conflicting evidence to the court. The Judge ruled that Mpshe's "sudden inexplicable turnaround was irrational". In the view of the court, at all material times, the decision of the NPA was to continue with the prosecution. There is no record of any change to that decision.
The court declared also that Mpshe made only a “half-hearted attempt” to investigate McCarthy’s abuse of process and kept Billy Downer in the dark about his decision to drop charges. The judge pointed out that the principle of audi alteram partem should have been applied and that both Bulelani Ngcuka and McCarthy should have been afforded the opportunity to defend themselves against the accusations that were brought against them. Mpshe did not do that.
Furthermore, Mpshe did not consult with his team before deciding to withdraw the charges against Zuma even though the decision was a “corporate decision”. In any case, the proper and logical course for Mpshe to have followed would have been the obvious one: leave it to the court to decide on whether the abuse of process by McCarthy was of such a nature as to warrant dropping the prosecution of Zuma. It was also inconceivable that Mpshe did not consult with the two senior independent counsels who were standing by before taking his decision not to proceed with the prosecution.
The judge was very surprised that in spite of an NPA decision to take action against McCarthy, Mpshe did not do so. Clearly it suited him to let the matter hang and to use the odour around it to justify the illogical decision he took.