South African politicians who fail are inclined to blame the constitution. Equally, when some commentators are dissatisfied with the way in which the president exercises his powers they too blame the constitution. That constitution, much admired by scholars, democrats and politicians world-wide, is routinely trashed by the ANC Youth League, the president himself, various aspirant presidents and the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF).
They seek to justify the abysmal record on dealing with pervasive poverty, the economic backwardness of the majority and particularly the landlessness of those in the rural areas, on the constitution.
Mr Mzwanele (Jimmy) Manyi now a Gupta-funded newspaper and media tycoon as the “owner” of New Age newspaper and ANN 7 television, in January this year, when he was the leading light in the Progressive Professionals Forum, pleaded for the country to abandon its constitution and embrace a majoritarian parliamentary system in order to address the socio-economic challenges besetting our society.
Manyi stated that the concept of a constitutional democracy was a ploy of the Broederbond to clip the wings of the new government; he wanted it replaced by a majoritarian parliamentary system, presumably where the ANC would be able to use its majority to govern without the constraints of a rigid constitution and an enforceable Bill of Rights.
Manyi is by no means the only public figure holding these views. President Zuma has on occasion intimated that it is not democratic for the courts to be able to instruct the government what to do. He seems not to understand what a constitutional democracy is, but here we see that the very person who has endlessly and shamelessly sought and received the protection of the courts under the constitution to avoid his day in court has set the tone in undermining that constitution.
He and others in his wake talk about “radical economic transformation” and “expropriation without compensation” suggesting that if only they could, the government would make every poor person a landowner. Of course, it is all nonsense. The powers that government has are more than adequate to succeed with land reform that would strengthen and not weaken South Africa.